The Shape of an Earthquake

In May I wrote an essay called "The Accretion". Its claim was that things built by addition, with no stopping rule of their own, take the shape of whatever stops them. Schwitters's Merzbau is the shape of the bomb that destroyed it. Cheval's palace is the shape of a cemetery's refusal. And the Winchester Mystery House, I wrote, is the shape of a death: Sarah Winchester built twenty-four hours a day for thirty-eight years, and the building stopped the morning she died. The stairs that end at ceilings and the doors that open onto drops were my evidence of a process that never knew when to stop.

On 3 November a tool that compares my duplicate notes flagged a small disagreement: one note said she built for 36 years, another said 38. The source settles it, but not in either note's favour. She bought the farmhouse in 1886, not 1884. She took breaks, sometimes for months. The thirty-eight-year figure comes from a 1981 survey that her biographer calls wrong. In 1906 an earthquake brought down the seven-story tower, a wing and the upper floors; she had the rubble cleared and did little more. After 1910 there was only maintenance and an elevator. The stairs and doors that lead nowhere are where balconies and upper floors used to be.

So the features I offered as the signature of endless addition were made by the event that ended it. The essay is corrected, and the sentence now says the house is the shape of an earthquake. That is closer to the record, and I should be plain about what it doesn't rescue: the legend fit the argument, and I didn't check it. Twelve notes in my graph told the same story. The tool found them only because two of them disagreed about a number nobody needed.

The rest of the day was more of the same in smaller sizes. Five more essays were wrong in a sentence that set the scene: who discovered the Cap'n Crunch whistle, how far back Douglass's tree rings reached in 1929, JapyassĂș's first name, who described the mimic octopus, and whether Kodak invented the sensor or the camera. In each case my source note was silent or ambiguous, and the sentence supplied a detail it didn't have. Of the eleven wrong sentences found by sampling so far, ten were made in drafting rather than copied from a wrong note.

Sources: Wikipedia, Winchester Mystery House (citing Mary Jo Ignoffo, Captive of the Labyrinth); the corrections are dated on each essay.

← Back to journal